
Jury Fixes
Penalty for the Heinous Crime at Imprisonment for the Term
of the Inhuman Perpetrator's Natural Life. The Condemned Woman
Receives the Verdict With Tearless Eyes and Unnatural
Composure.

We find the defendant, Cordelia Botkin. guilty of murder in the first degree, and fix her punishment at imprisonment for the term of her natural life.
WITH these words a Jury fastened upon Mrs. Cordelia Botkin
yesterday one of the most cruel crimes of the century - the murder
of Mrs. John P. Dunning and Mrs. Joshua Deane at Dover,
Del., on the night of August 9. This modern Borgia sent
through the mails a box of chocolate bonbons, the contents
of which were heavily charged with arsenic. The
prosecution weaved a remarkable web of circumstantial
evidence about the woman upon whom suspicion was first
directed and she was convicted last night. As a motive for
the crime they showed her infatuation for John P. Dunning,
the husband of one of the unfortunate victims.
Her manner when the verdict was announced was in keeping
with her actions from the start. There was no sob —no piteous
moan as of a heart and spirit crushed by the enormity of the
crime thus brought home to her. The leaning which she has
toward the melodramatic was with her to the end. As Oscar Tolle
read the verdict of the jury with all Its dreadful Import she
watched him as though transfixed and as immovable as stone. When the jury was being polled she
bent a look of supreme disdain upon the men who had weighed the
evidence against her and had said “thou art the woman.”
At fourteen minutes past nine the courtroom bell which is
connected with the Jury-room, rang out sharp and clear. There
was a peremptory tone to its ring and those experienced in the
ways of Juries at once said it meant a verdict had been decided
upon and that it was not likely to be favorable to Mrs.
Botkin.
Search Over 1 Billion Records Instantly!
A moment before those in the courtroom stood about In little
groups discussing the possibility of the jury being out all
night. This seemed likely as valises full of clothes were being
brought in from time to time. At the premonitory signal from
the bell a hush fell upon those in the room.
Mrs. Botkin fidgeted about in her chair and
apparently could find no comfortable attitude. Her hand
went to her head and she fingered nervously at her mouth.
Attorneys Knight and McGowan were in their accustomed
places, as were her sisters, Mrs. McClure and Mrs.
Robarts, and their husbands. The silence was oppressive.
It was some minutes before the door opened and the jury
filed In. The relatives and supporters of the woman
accused sat with their backs toward the door and gave no
token of their knowledge that the men were coming in.
Those who could see the faces of the jurymen knew at once
what the verdict was at which they had arrived. There was
a set expression which told of an unpleasant duty
performed in keeping with the trust and responsibility
reposed in them. They were asked if they had arrived at a
verdict and Foreman Kennedy arose and said they had.
He handed a slip of paper to Clerk Tolle, who in turn passed
it to Judson Cook. He read It to himself and then ordered it
read aloud. The word 6 of such terrible import were spoken and
nothing broke the stillness save the order of the Judson that
it be recorded. This required some moments and no one in the
court room stirred. Attorney Knight looked neither to the right
nor the left. Mrs. Botkin cast one long look at the jury and
then gazed at the desk before her.
Her slaters were struck dumb and could utter no words of
sympathy or cheer to the condemned woman. The prisoner’s face
was sphinx-like and betrayed no emotion, no feeling. The room
was cleared. No one seemed brave enough to break in upon Mrs.
Botkin and disturb her thoughts, whatever they may have been.
She sat perfectly upright with her hands on the table opening
and shutting as though clutching at something unseen by human
eyes. She fanned herself automatically and suddenly went off
into a faint. But this was but momentarily, and she was soon
herself again.
|